$5 Secret Sister Gifts

$5 Secret Sister Gifts!

We specialize in Christian gifts for women, including $5 gifts for your Secret Sister, your Secret Pal, or your Secret Santa!

FAITH Cloth Bookmark

$5.00

Shop

Put On Love Lanyard

$4.99

Shop

Fish and Cross Window Decals

$4.99

Shop

Proverbs 4:4 Bookmark

$5.00

Shop

"Friend Loves" Metal Bookmark

$5.00

Shop

"With God" Metal Bookmark

$5.00

Shop

"New Creation" Metal Bookmark

$5.00

Shop

Hope Pin

$5.00

Shop

Brown Mug Cozy (without mug)

$5.00

Shop

Aqua Blue Mug Cozy (without mug)

$5.00

Shop

Chandelier Earrings

$10.00 $3.00

Shop

Faith Large Button Dome Magnet

$5.00

Shop

Large FAITH Magnet

$5.00

Shop

Golden Earth Metal Bookmark

$5.00

Shop

But First Coffee Towel

$5.00

Shop

Be Joyful Always Wood Block

$4.99

Shop

Do What You Love Notebook

$4.99 $2.50

Shop

Do It With Passion Notebook

$4.99 $2.50

Shop

Dot Paper Pink Sketchbook

$4.99

Shop

"Wash and Pray" Germ Free Key

$6.99 $1.99

Shop

Live Simple Zipper Pouch with Tassel

$4.99

Shop

Happy Day Necklace

$4.99

Shop

Agenda Notebook Lined Journal with Flowers

$4.99

Shop

Agenda Notebook Lined Journal with Buffalo Check Pattern

$4.99

Shop

Floral Flip Notebook

$4.99

Shop

Farmhouse Flip Notebook

$4.99

Shop

180 Prayers To Change The World

$4.99

Shop

Pink and Wood Cross Bracelet

$5.00

Shop

Gold Cross Tassel Keyring

$5.00

Shop

Pink Cross Tassel Keyring

$5.00

Shop

Rhinestone Cross Elegant Keyring

$5.00

Shop

Mighty Keyring with Blue Tassel

$5.00

Shop

Prayed For Child Necklace

$5.00

Shop

God Gave Me You Necklace

$5.00

Shop

Be Brave Bookmark

$5.99 $4.99

Shop

She Is Loved Bookmark

$5.99 $4.99

Shop

You Got This! Lapel Pin

$5.00

Shop

Awesome Lapel Pin

$5.00

Shop

Fabulous Lapel Pin

$5.00

Shop

Dream Big Lapel Pin

$5.00

Shop

I'm A Big Deal Lapel Pin

$5.00

Shop

Noel Wood Bead Ornament

$4.99

Shop

Serve The Lord Shelf Jar

$4.99

Shop

Blessed & Grateful Shelf Jar

$4.99

Shop

Wire Wrapped Heart Wall Cross

$4.99

Shop

Uniquely Created Scripture Shareables

$4.99

Shop

It Is Well With My Soul Shelf Sign

$4.99

Shop

Gather Here Magnet

$4.99

Shop

Amazing Grace Magnet

$4.99

Shop

Rock Faith Notebook and Pen

$4.99

Shop

Pray More Notebook and Pen

$4.99

Shop

Be-You-Tiful Notebook and Pen

$4.99

Shop

You Got This! Coffee Pin

$4.99 $2.49

Shop

Secret Sister Donut Pin

$4.99 $2.49

Shop

He Is Risen Cross Pin

$4.99

Shop

Navy Gold Crochet Flower Bookmark

$7.99 $3.99

Shop

Amazonite Stone Cross Bracelet

$4.99

Shop

Gold Wrapped Cross Earrings

$4.99 $2.50

Shop

Silver Wrapped Cross Earrings

$4.99 $2.50

Shop

Gold Cross Outline Earrings

$4.99 $2.50

Shop

Silver Cross Outline Earrings

$4.99 $2.50

Shop

Copper Cross Outline Earrings

$4.99 $2.50

Shop

Antique Gold Cross Outline Earrings

$4.99 $2.50

Shop

Copper Wrapped Cross Earrings

$4.99 $2.50

Shop

Antique Gold Wrapped Cross Earrings

$4.99 $2.50

Shop

Butterfly Pin - Let Go and Let God

$4.99

Shop

Jeweled Hat Pin

$4.99

Shop

Grateful Heart Earrings

$4.99

Shop

Focus On The Good Flower Earrings

$4.99

Shop

Don't Doubt Your Worth Rhinestone Earrings

$4.99

Shop

Focus On The Good Leaf Earrings

$4.99

Shop

Spirit Lead Me Dove Earrings

$4.99

Shop

1 2

Secret Sister Gifts Under $5:

Navy Floral Wristlet Key Ring

$3.99 $1.99

Shop

Aqua Wristlet Key Ring

$3.99 $1.99

Shop

"Shine On" Cord Wrap

$2.49

Shop

"Let's Be Buds" Cord Wrap

$2.49

Shop

Mini "Sister" Photo Frame

$4.00

Shop

Love the Lord Metal Bookmark

$2.00

Shop

Mini Floral Card

$0.69 $0.35

Shop

Gift Wrapping Service

$3.00

Shop

Love Never Fails Magnet

$4.49

Shop

It Is Well Magnet

$4.49

Shop

Bless This Nest Magnet

$3.49

Shop

Love Is All You Need Heart

$3.49

Shop

Today is the Day Notebook

$3.99

Shop

Heart Notebook

$3.99

Shop

All You Need Is Love Magnet

$3.49

Shop

"That's a Wrap!" Cord Wrap

$2.49

Shop

Purple Flower Magnet "You Are Loved"

$3.49 $0.99

Shop

Teal Aqua Flower Magnet "Gift From Secret Sister"

$1.99 $0.99

Shop

Where There Is Love Wooden Tag

$3.49

Shop

God's Grace Protects You Wooden Tag

$3.49

Shop

Love You To The Moon And Back Wooden Tag

$3.49

Shop

My Prayer Box Floral Tin

$3.99

Shop

The NLT Bible Promise Book for Women

$2.99

Shop

The NLT Promise Book for Tough Times

$2.99

Shop

Choose Gratitude Leaf Magnet

$3.99

Shop

John 3:16 Cross Magnet

$3.99

Shop

"Baked from the Kitchen of" Tag Set

$3.99

Shop

You Are Loved Striped Magnet

$2.99

Shop

All Things Possible Long Magnet

$1.99

Shop

Fancy Wooden Cross Ornament

$3.99

Shop

Wooden Cross Floral Ornament

$3.99

Shop

Fearfully & Wonderfully Made Magnet

$3.99

Shop

Bless Our Home Wreath Magnet

$2.99

Shop

You Can Be Anything - Be Kind Magnet

$2.99

Shop

Do All Things With Love Magnet

$2.99

Shop

Pack of 3 Inspirational Bookmarks

$2.99

Shop

Autumn Day Gift Enclosure

$0.99

Shop

Enjoy This Day Gift Enclosure

$0.99

Shop

So Very Blessed Gift Enclosure

$0.99

Shop

Yellow Glitter Cupcake Gift Tag

$0.99

Shop

Blue Glitter Cupcake Gift Tag

$0.99

Shop

Aqua Sparkle Cupcake Gift Tag

$0.99

Shop

Gold Sparkle Cupcake Gift Tag

$0.99

Shop

God Is Love Gift Tag

$0.99

Shop

It's A New Day Gift Tag

$0.99

Shop

God Loved Us First Gift Tag

$0.99

Shop

Jesus Loves Me Gift Tag

$0.99

Shop

Faith Hope Charity Gift Tag

$0.99

Shop

Things Above Gift Tag

$0.99

Shop

Praise Him Gift Tag

$0.99

Shop

Trust In The Lord Gift Tag

$0.99

Shop

Good Courage Gift Tag

$0.99

Shop

Love One Another Gift Tag

$0.99

Shop

Pumpkin Mini Card

$0.99 $0.69

Shop

Secret Sister Mini Card

$0.99 $0.69

Shop

Small Things, Great Love Gift Tag Bookmark

$1.99

Shop

Love of God Gift Tag Bookmark

$1.99

Shop

You Are Loved Gift Tag Bookmark

$1.99

Shop

Drawstring Fall Fleece Bag with Thankful Tag

$5.00 $3.50

Shop

Secret Pal Pocket Card

$0.99

Shop

Set of Floral Note Cards

$3.99

Shop

Silver Twist Cross Bracelet

$9.99 $4.00

Shop

Possible Starts Here Box of Note Paper

$3.49

Shop

I'm Sending You a Hug Today Magnet

$4.49

Shop

Pink Flower Crocheted Bookmark with Tag

$3.99

Shop

Secret Sister Gold Heart Magnet

$2.99

Shop

Share His Love - Cookie Cutter

$3.99

Shop

Psalm 23:6 Bookmark

$3.99

Shop

Romans 8:28 Bookmark

$3.99

Shop

Happy Day Carrot Decoration

$3.49

Shop

Simple Prayers of Blessings

$3.99

Shop

Special Friend Memo Pad

$3.99

Shop

1 2